This recipe for a sweet, nutty and slightly fruity Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake can be adapted to suit your mood. Keep it relatively healthy & simple or indulge to make a thick, creamy and extravagant ice cream shake.
Peanut butter flapjack would be the ideal treat to serve with your shake.
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email and we’ll send the link straight to your inbox. Plus, you'll receive my trusted recipes each week!
Last week I was battling transatlantic terminology for my lime and courgette cake. This week, I’m pleased to report, I have no such qualms. Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches are as American as it gets, so I’m turning American-English for one week only. It’s out with the jam and in with the jelly for this PB&J creation. That’s just as well, since the inspiration for this Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake came whilst on holiday in Florida recently.
It goes without saying that peanut butter & jelly sandwiches are a definite American childhood classic. But, I have to be honest; it’s not a sandwich filling that naturally wins favour here in the UK. In fact, I’m sitting here with my fingers double-crossed hoping that my lovely UK readers do not tune out at the mere mention of peanut butter and jelly. (Please don’t – you’ll miss out.)
I’m also sitting here about to make a confession many die-hard Peanut Butter & Jelly enthusiasts the world over may not forgive me for… ever.
Confession: I’m not hugely into Peanut Butter & Jelly sandwiches. Nor is my family. Sorry. I know, I know. This revelation is verging on criminal!
However, our favourite way to eat PB&J is blended into a milkshake. We first tried this combination whilst in DisneyWorld 3 years ago and it was just as good this year when we went back. If you’ve been reading LittleSugarSnaps for long, you’ll no doubt have spotted my habit of recreating tasty holiday finds. The Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake was one such discovery we couldn’t quite leave behind us. You’ll find plenty more in my cold drink recipes section.
The shakes we had on holiday were extremely thick and decadent. But, being me (sensible Mother type) I wanted to create a drink that was less extravagant. But one that could be pimped on those occasions when it’s ok to outrageously splash out.
The recipe listed below uses reduced sugar jelly and a few dates. I’ve also kept the ice cream out of the blender and it’s entirely optional whether or not to top each glass with a scoop of ice cream. Either way, it’s delicious. This Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake delivers a sweet, nutty flavour with just a hint of fruity jelly.
I’m not sure my choices make this an entirely virtuous drink, but it is a relatively healthy version of the Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake we developed a crush on in DisneyWorld. (For a healthier shake try my date shake – it tastes sinful but it’s really not that unhealthy at all).
The base recipe can be easily adapted to suit your tastes, what you have in your store cupboard or your desire to indulge:
- It works well with regular jelly instead of reduced-sugar
- Choose grape, raspberry or strawberry jelly (and use more or less depending how sweet you like your shakes)
- The dates are optional (leave them out for a less sweet drink)
- Blend a couple of scoops of ice cream directly into the shake
- Go dairy free by using milk & ice cream substitutes
It’s really up to you to decide how indulgent you’d like this shake to be. This shake is lovely without any ice cream, but a thicker, creamier and altogether more wicked shake can be crafted by adding a few scoops to the blender. Just saying.
More Child Friendly Drinks:
Stay in touch: sign up to receive LittleSugarSnaps newsletters to hear when new recipes are published. Or follow me on social media:
📖 Recipe
Want to Save This Recipe?
Enter your email and we’ll send the link straight to your inbox. Plus, you’ll receive my trusted recipes each week!
Peanut Butter & Jelly Milkshake
Ingredients
- 360ml/ 1 ½ cups Whole (Full fat) Milk
- 3 Dates – pitted
- 2 tbsp Peanut butter (crunchy or smooth)
- 2 tablespoon Reduced Sugar Jelly (grape, raspberry or strawberry) seedless
- Handful ice
- 3 scoops Vanilla ice cream optional
Garnish
- 1 tbsp peanut butter optional
- 1 tbsp Reduced Sugar Jelly optional
- 2 scoops vanilla ice cream optional
Instructions
- Put the milk, dates, peanut butter, jelly, ice and ice cream (if using) into a blender and blitz until smooth
- Wipe the additional peanut butter and jelly around the side of the serving glasses (if using)
- Pour the shake into the glasses
- Top with a scoop of ice cream (if using)
- Serve immediately
Notes
- The peanut butter can be smooth or crunchy, store bought or homemade.
- The Jelly can be reduced sugar or regular and can be grape, raspberry or strawberry flavoured
- Leave out the dates for a less sweet drink
- Experiment with non-dairy milk.
sue | theviewfromgreatisland
This is utterly brilliant, and the perfect after school treat, I’m sharing today on facebook!
Jane Saunders
Thanks so much Sue!
Nicola @ Happy Healthy Motivated
I don’t normally like PB&J anything, but these milkshakes look way too adorable to resist!
Jane Saunders
I hope I manage to win you over with these shakes – they are way better than a sandwich.
Tricia @ Saving Room for Dessert
I must be the only American who never has eaten a PB&J sandwich and never plan to – haha. But I would drink this lovely combination. I do love both peanut butter and jam (especially homemade) but not on bread. Weird I know. This is wonderful and creative and so pretty.
Jane Saunders
We are on exactly the same wavelength Tricia – I think it’s a texture thing for me. I like alot of crunch between my bread. Hopefully you can add this shake to your list of non-sandwich ways to enjoy the combination.
Liz @ I Heart Vegetables
Yum!!! I’ve never had a PB&J milkshake but I love the combo of sweet and salty flavors!
Jane Saunders
Thanks Liz. I hope you get to try one to experience the flavours – it’s nothing like the sandwich.
Helen @ Fuss Free Flavours
I think the combination of peanut butter and jelly (jam) is rather underestimated by those that think it just won’t go. From my experience, American peanut butter tends to be sweeter (eg Jif), and the jelly is less jam like, as we have here in The UK. But it still goes well together. Don’t knock it until you try it kind of thing.
Back on track to your American inspired creation, and I think it sounds rather fab. Not something you’d have regularly, but great for barbeques, for kids parties, or one of those things you just fancy on a whim.
Jane Saunders
Thanks Helen. It would definitely fit in well for a themed party or BBQ wouldn’t it. Or maybe to accompany viewing the Super Bowl. Re jam v jelly, yes, I think you are right – I’ve recommended a seedless jam to get around this for those not able to lay their hands on true American jelly – I’ve tried this recipe with both and they both work well in this shake.