Maine Whoopie Pies with Pumpkin

These easy to make Maine Whoopie Pies are packed with pumpkin & autumn spices and they have the most amazing marshmallow buttercream centre. Plain Delicious.

[mv_video key=”goynavhriyl2iepvpjts” volume=”70″ aspectRatio=”true” title=”Sweet Treats on LittleSugarSnaps” thumbnail=”https://mediavine-res.cloudinary.com/video/upload/goynavhriyl2iepvpjts.jpg” doNotOptimizePlacement=”undefined” doNotAutoplayNorOptimizePlacement=”false” sticky=”false”]

Crisp morning air and noticeably shorter days mean one thing – autumn has arrived. For me, this signifies a shift in baking patterns – everything must take on an air of cosiness, which brings me to these Maine whoopie pies with pumpkin.

Whoopie pies are the official State treat in Maine, USA. Don’t you just love the idea of an official treat? My rendition, loaded with pumpkin and sweet spices, fully embraces the cooler season and they are a longstanding favourite with my family at this time of year.

Why this Recipe is Worth Making

Maine whoopie pies are really a cross between cakes and cookies. Each one comprises two domes of cake that are sandwiched together with a creamy filling. 

I like to think of them as free-form individual sandwich cakes as you just dollop the cake batter straight onto baking trays and away you go. No fiddling with paper cake cases involved. Easy!

These pies contain three elements that make them irresistible:

• fresh pumpkin that delivers a delicate sweet flavour and imparts a wonderful autumnal hue to the batter
• pumpkin spice – cinnamon, cloves, ginger, mace, allspice and nutmeg all mixed up in a bowl filling your kitchen with a warming and cosy aroma
• the filling – closely related to buttercream, but involving vanilla and marshmallow – posh buttercream, if you like

These are the star components in this straightforward and rather charming adaptation of Maine whoopie pies.

Ingredients

I’ve chosen to make a fresh purée for these pumpkin whoopie pies as I much prefer fresh to canned, especially in this recipe. You can, however, use canned purée if that’s your preference or if fresh pumpkin is out of season.

Pumpkin purée freezes very well, so I tend to cook the whole pumpkin up and save the leftovers for other baking projects.

Do ensure that you select a pumpkin that is intended to be eaten. Not only are culinary grade pumpkins a better size (not too large) they are also much tastier than the larger pumpkins grown for carving.

As the flavour of spices can quickly deteriorate, I always make my own pumpkin spice mix. And I make it in small batches, so that I’m guaranteed a fresh hit of flavour.

I’ve included my own blend in the recipe below, but, if you already have a favourite pumpkin spice mix, feel free to use that instead.

And if you are looking for something fun to bake with the kids to use up leftover pumpkin puree and pumpkin spice take a look at these easy Pumpkin Pie Twists.

Step By Step Instructions

Though easy to make, there are a few stages to complete when making these Maine whoopie pies:

1. Make the fresh pumpkin purée
2. Mix the pumpkin spice
3. Bake the pies
4. Make the buttercream and sandwich the pie halves togehter

It’s great if you can get the first stage done well in advance to give the purée time to cool completely.

Stage 1: Make the Pumpkin Purée

Step 1: Cut the pumpkin in half vertically and scoop out the seeds

Step 2: Place cut side down on a baking tin lined with parchment and roast for 60-75 minutes at 200C/ 400F/ GM 6 until the flesh is soft when poked with a sharp knife

Step 3: Let cool slightly, then scoop out the flesh and purée it all in a food processor until smooth

Step 4: Let cool completely, then store in the fridge until ready to use

Stage 2: Make the Pumpkin Spice Mix

Nice and easy – simply mix all the spice blend ingredients together and store in an airtight jar (keeps for around 3 months).

Stage 3: Make the Pies

Step 1: Sift the flour, baking powder, bicarbonate of soda, spice mix and salt together into a bowl. Set aside

Step 2: Put the oil, sugar and vanilla bean paste into a large bowl and mix with electric beaters until well combined

Step 3: Add the pumpkin purée and mix briefly

Step 4: Crack the egg in and give another quick beat

Step 5: Add half of the flour mixture and blend well on medium speed, scraping the edges of the bowl to incorporate all dry ingredients. Add the remaining flour and mix again, being careful to not overbeat

Step 6: Use a dessert spoon or ice cream scoop with a release mechanism to drop about 1 ½ tablespoon of the batter onto prepared baking sheets, about one inch apart.(Use less batter for smaller cookies)

Step 7: Bake for 12-14 minutes, until golden and springy to the touch. Cool on the baking sheet for a minute then transfer to a wire cooling rack

Stage 4: Assembling the Pies

Step 1: Make the filling by sieving the icing sugar and beating together with the butter

Step 2: Next beat in the cream cheese and the vanilla bean paste

Step 3: Mix in the marshmallow fluff and beat until completely smooth

Step 4: Once the cake domes are completely cool, pair up similar shapes & sizes, then pipe buttercream onto one half and sandwich the two halves together

When ready to serve, dust the tops of the pumpkin whoopie pies with a little icing sugar

Expert Tips and FAQs

Expert Tips

These Maine whoopie pies are very easy to make, but as with most bakes there are a few things to keep in mind when making this recipe to ensure success:

• It is vital to allow the pumpkin puree to cool to at least room temperature before using it in this recipe otherwise it will activate the baking powder before the pies get to the oven. Use either room temperature or chilled puree instead
• When it comes to putting the mixture onto the baking sheet you can either use a spoon, a cookie scoop or even an ice cream scoop. Just keep in mind the size of the tool you are using in relation to how many whoopie pies you intend to make and swap for a smaller/ larger tool as necessary
• I don’t recommend piping the mixture onto the baking sheet as this will deflate the air that has been beaten into the batter
• Ensure you create an even number of cake batter portions on the baking sheet so you don’t’ have a lonely pie dome leftover
• I’ve stated that the recipe makes 8 large pies, These have a diameter of approximately 6-7 cm. You can, of course, make smaller pies. This recipe could comfortably produce 10-12 such pies
• When assembling the whoopie pies, rather than randomly picking up a large dome and sandwiching it together with a smaller dome, do take the time to pair domes of similar shapes & sizes. The end result will look better if you do
• Finally, to produce a lovely neat finish to these Maine whoopie pies, pipe the buttercream onto one dome of each pie before topping with the other dome. It looks so much neater than if the buttercream has been slathering on with a knife

Frequently Asked Questions

Have you spotted my other recipes featuring pumpkin spice?

If you like the sound of these Maine whoopie pies with pumpkin you may also like the following recipes:

• Pumpkin Spice Marshmallows – plus instructions for compiling a dessert dipping bar which is great for parties
• Chocolate Pumpkin Spice Granola
• Pumpkin Spice Toffee
• Pumpkin Spice Bundt Cake – this one also contains pumpkin puree

If you tried these Maine whoopie pies with pumpkin please give it a rating below. Don’t forget to share your creations with me on Instagram too – I love to hear how you’ve got along. Use #littlesugarsnaps and tag me @jane_littlesugarsnaps.

📖 Recipe