Name: Chocolate Caramel Spread
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 20 min
Total time: 30 min
Ingredients: 225 g/ 5/8 cup Caster sugar (white); 100 ml/ 1/3 cup + 4 tsp Water ((cold)); 120 g/ 1/2 cup Butter; 150 ml/ 2/3 cup Double cream (heavy cream); 1/4 tsp Sea salt crystals (add an extra 1/2 tsp for salted caramel); 1/2 tsp Vanilla extract; 80 g/ 1/2 cup Milk chocolate (finely chopped)

Jump to Recipe Pin Recipe

Chocolate Caramel Spread is as good as it sounds. A dreamy caramel concoction, thick enough to spread and laced with a generous hint of milk chocolate. Go all out and add a kick of salt to turn it into Chocolate Salted Caramel Spread.

Chocolate Caramel Spread in small jars with chopped chocolate alongside.

Decisions decisions. All day I’ve been debating whether to bump a winter salad recipe and, you guessed it, in the end, I couldn’t resist. That means I have something savoury and healthy to present next week, as a light interlude, before it’s full steam ahead on the treats front until January.

But enough of what’s to come, this Chocolate Caramel Spread is begging for our full attention today. The first thing to note is my decision to call this a caramel spread. Caramel is 100% the star of the show here with chocolate as a secondary flavour. This spread is rich and buttery, with a texture that is most definitely that of caramel – smooth, silky and gloriously thick. So really, it is quite different to chocolate spread on many levels.

This gem of a recipe has been idling its time away in my notebooks for a number of years. But last week one of my kids politely requested I make it again soon. Okay, she begged me to make it. So I did – yesterday. I knew straight away that it should make it’s way onto LittleSugarSnaps at the earliest possible moment, so I snapped the pictures today and poor Mr Lentil Salad got banished to oblivion for a week.

As it happens, I’m pleased I held fire on publishing the recipe for this Chocolate Caramel Spread for a while. It originally started life as a Chocolate Salted Caramel Spread. But really, it works just as well as regular caramel without the salt. But here’s the best bit – it is customisable:

If you feel like going the whole hog, add some extra salt to the recipe to turn the whole batch into Chocolate Salted Caramel Spread
If you are sitting on the fence, keep the recipe plain, but scatter a few tiny flakes of sea salt onto the caramel spread as it is served as and when your salty mood arises

That should cover all caramel mood bases that could overcome us.

Chocolate Caramel Spread being spread on a small brioche roll.

When it comes to cooking the caramel, as ever, I recommend not rushing it. Let the caramel take its sweet time and turn a beautiful shade of amber. And for this, I have a culinary analogy. I think of caramel as I would a steak. It can be cooked to varying degrees:

rare (very light amber)
rare-medium (light amber)
medium (mid amber)
medium-well done (dark amber)
well done (very dark amber)

For this Chocolate Caramel Spread, I recommend cooking the caramel to between medium and medium-well done (aka mid-dark amber). Keep your eye on the pan and do not let the caramel get too dark, else the spread will display unpleasant bitter notes when eaten.

This caramel can be eaten straight from the fridge but it is better after it has sat at room temperature for 20 minutes. Serve with:

toast & crumpets
brioche & croissants
sandwiched in a sponge cake
on pancakes
as a dip for apple wedges or plain biscuits

And if you can handle parting with a jar or two, decant into small jars for a thoughtful foodie gift.

A pot of Chocolate Caramel Spread and chopped chocolate alongside.

Find more delicious spreads to try out:

📖 Recipe

Chocolate Caramel Spread

Jane Coupland

4.43 from 7 votes

Print Pin Rate

Course: Side Dish

Cuisine: Worldwide

Diet: Vegetarian

Prep Time: 10

Cook Time: 20

Total Time: 30

Servings: Jar

Calories: 2648kcal

Ingredients

▢ 225 g/ ⅝ cup Caster sugar white
▢ 100 ml/ ⅓ cup + 4 tsp Water (cold)
▢ 120 g/ ½ cup Butter
▢ 150 ml/ ⅔ cup Double cream heavy cream
▢ ¼ teaspoon Sea salt crystals add an extra ½ teaspoon for salted caramel
▢ ½ teaspoon Vanilla extract
▢ 80 g/ ½ cup Milk chocolate finely chopped

Instructions

Put the sugar into a heavy based saucepan and pour the water over it. Cook over a low-medium heat to allow the sugar to dissolve (5-10 minutes)
Meanwhile, cube the butter
Once the sugar has dissolved, turn the heat to medium and allow the caramel to continue to cook until it reaches a rich amber colour – another 5-10 minutes (but be careful not to let the caramel burn and turn bitter)
Take off the heat and add ⅓ of the butter, mixing with a mini balloon whisk – it will rise and splutter a little, so be careful. Add another ⅓ butter, mix and then add the remaining butter. Mix again
Pour in the cream, vanilla extract and the salt (either ¼ tsp or ¾ tsp depending on your preference for regular caramel or salted caramel). Mix
Add the chocolate and beat with the balloon whisk until melted
Pass the caramel through a metal sieve, using a metal spoon to push the sauce through. This will ensure the caramel spread is lump free
Decant into small jars, let cool, then seal and store in the fridge
Let sit for 20 minutes before using

Notes

If the caramel cooks for too long, there is a chance the caramel will be too stiff to spread. If so, heat in the microwave on a low setting in short 10-second bursts until a spreading consistency is reached. Do not blast it at full power, else the spread will return to liquid form.

Alternatively, reheat the entire batch gently, to melt, and stir through a little extra cream – 1 or 2 tbsp, depending on how thick the spread is – then let it reset.

Nutrition Per Serving (Approximate)

Tried this Recipe? Pin it Today!Mention @littlesugarsnap or tag #littlesugarsnaps!

(Visited 28 times, 1 visits today)

Jane Saunders

February 14, 2021 at 1:14 pm

Hi Bob, first of all, how frustrating that my recipe has not worked out as planned for you. I only ever publish recipes that I have tested numerous times and that I’m therefore 100% confident in. I never like to hear of recipes not working for readers, but it does occasionally happen. My aim is always to troubleshoot when things do go wrong so that I can help identify the problem for yourself and for other readers interested in a recipe. With this in mind, I’d love your help to try to work out what could have gone wrong here:
1. Usually, when caramel does not set as expected it’s because it has not been cooked for quite long enough. It’s a fine balance between achieving that rich amber colour and burning the caramel here, so can I check how far you did cook it? Did you go for pale amber or did you let it cook down to a darker amber?
2. Adding too much liquid would certainly affect the ability for this spread to set? Did you measure out the water and cream to the exact amounts specified in the recipe? (apologies if that seems like a basic question, but measuring is critcal for caramel recipes like this)
3. And talking of cream, it should be double cream (or an equivalent cream with a fat content of around 48%) – I’m not sure where in the world you live, but I know that creams can vary significantly
4. Did you use proper block butter or a butter alternative, spread or oil? Block butter is the one and only ingredients to use here since it solidifies when cool
5. The chocolate should be regular chocolate, not candy melts or cooking chocolate

Those are the most likely culprits for the caramel spread not setting as it should do. Let me know if any of these chime with you. Though your spread has turned out runny I hope you can enjoy the flavour, perhaps using it as a sauce for ice cream or pancakes etc.